Third Track Faces Support, Criticism


Long Islanders gathered at numerous community centers last week, to voice their opinion on Governor Andrew Cuomo’s plan to add a third track on the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) between Floral Park and Hicksville.

The plan has drawn support and opposition and both those opinions were voiced during six public scoping meetings held by the MTA/LIRR last week in New Hyde Park, Westbury, Hicksville and at Hofstra University.

Lisa Black, from Governor Andrew Cuomo’s office, explains the changes the third
Lisa Black, from Governor Andrew Cuomo’s office, explains the changes the third

“We want to find out concerns and enter every comment into the review process for the project,” said MTA spokesman Aaron Donovan, adding that the scoping sessions are the beginning phase of the project, which will help the MTA determine what to focus on in the environmental review process. “Step one is to get the public’s input to help define what needs to be studied. Once we have those parameters, we’ll begin the main part of the environmental impact study.”

The MTA released scoping documents online on May 5, which explained the need for the project and what environmental issues should be studied. The governor has said adding a third track along the corridor will help relieve peak hour congestion on trains and roads, prevent delays and increase service to employment centers on Long Island.

Paul Floroff, a Glen Head resident, attended public hearings on the third track project when it was proposed about eight years ago and said he came to the meeting at Hofstra last week to show his support once again.

“I think it’s long overdue,” he said. “I’ve read too many stories about people who are intoxicated and driving on our highways. By improving public transit, we can help reduce the major crisis of impaired driving.”

Westbury’s John Michno said adding more service via a third track would be a huge help.

“We need a more reliable mainline,” Michno said, adding that there were often long waits in between trains outside of rush hour. “Many in our community rely on public transportation to get around and the current situation is a hardship. I don’t know how anyone could be opposed to this.”

Garden City Mayor Nicholas Episcopia voiced his opposition to the third track, saying he didn’t see the benefit it would bring to central Nassau.

“We hear this is going to be a great economic boom, but we don’t really know how or why,” Episcopia said. “Many of the people I spoke to think this is nothing but a third track to service Suffolk County. We just don’t see the economic benefit for central Nassau County, which will bear the burden of the disruption.”

He went on to say that prior to the announcement of the third track project, LIRR president Patrick Nowakowski had said delays on the railroad were caused by an antiquated switch system.

“I sincerely hope the switches and other important repairs and improvements are done before anybody considers a third track,” said Episcopia. “This entire process was rushed. It’s very unfair.”

Several residents who live alongisde the tracks cited noise and vibrations from the trains as their biggest worries.

“This is disturbing our way of life,” said Mineola’s Anahit Shishmanian. “With two trains passing by it already makes a lot of noise and vibration. I don’t think they can fix that. That’s not the quality of life I want to live.”

While no definite plans have been released, the project officials said they are looking into barrier walls to abate noise and vibrations. Donovan said that more details about the whole project will be provided throughout the environmental study process. The public can comment on the project until June 13 at or by visiting the project information center at the Mineola Station-South Platform. The MTA expects to release a draft environmental impact statement later this year and a public comment period for that document will follow thereafter.

Leave a Reply